Is 2=1?
Now we start
the proof.
First,
[multiply both side by a] a² = ab
[subtract b² from both side] a²-b² = ab-b²
[factorise the equation] (a-b)(a+b)
= b(a-b)
[both side divide by (a-b)] a+b = b
Since a=b, then we have 2b = b
[divide both side by b] 2 = 1
Does 2 really equals to one? What’s wrong with this proof? Where does
the logic break down?
Actually, the method of getting the solution was not
mathematically sound. This was a fake proof.
Still remember that we let a=b
before we start the proof?
If a=b, then
a-b=0.
Hence, the proof above cannot divide by a-b, because it will be divide
by 0.
The division by 0 is also undefined.
Hence, we cannot conclude that the
number 2 is equals to 1.
~Ewe Sin Hooi
No comments:
Post a Comment